You know, when I read that article yesterday, I was literally going to quote that paragraph here because it really bugged me, but I got sidetracked and forgot all about it! Good to see I'm not the only one who noticed that ridiculous swipe.
I will grant that the makers of Hong Kong TV shows never seemed interested in building up an international, pan-cultural interest in their product, and certainly never shot the curl the way the Koreans are right now, but implying that Hong Kong television is somehow "unimaginative and serious" simply because it's
not Korean television, as if that even counts as a qualitative arguement, is more than a little silly.
She's clearly a fan of the stuff, rather than a serious pop culture sociologist, which explains the rather broad, simplistic labelling of Korean TV soaps as "innovated and well edited...ingenious and fun."
Like others here, I enjoy a lot of Korean soaps, but I'd be hard pressed to call the vast majority of them "ingenious," and in fact, if you watch enough of them in succession, even while trying to mix genres a little bit, you can't help but notice the repetitive themes that tend to fuel a lot of Korean entertainment, the TV segment of which has of late started to become derivative
of itself (which is still not necessarily a bad thing, if you keep your expectations somewhere in the middle of the road). I think the sheer
prettyness of all the people in these shows tends to set the hearts of people like Amiee Dawis aflutter, and common sense goes out the window.
Mind you, while it's nice to see more Hong Kong TV shows available with English subtitles—there still doesn't seem to be enough of it about to indicate their makers see much of a market outside of the Chinas and the Chinese diaspora. Perhaps when the trendiness inevitably wears off of the Korean soaps, some enterprising HK company will start pimping HK's television product beyond its intended audience.
Of course, they might have to do more shows centered around beautiful blind orphan girls who get involved in love quadrangles and die of tragic diseases to help ween people off the K-stuff, but hey, if that's what it takes...
