i havent got that version ill shamefuly admit i was desperate to see the film and got a copied version

Safe to assume you are referring to SPL in this new thread. Any way an editor can megre these threads somehow?

Regardless, I suspect both you and Evirei would be very, VERY well served to get the official edition from Hong Kong, although some of the effect will have possibly been muted from watching the truncated version. Suffice to say, A LOT happens after Donnie pours himself a drink!

Brian Thibodeau wrote:Safe to assume you are referring to SPL in this new thread. Any way an editor can megre these threads somehow?

Regardless, I suspect both you and Evirei would be very, VERY well served to get the official edition from Hong Kong, although some of the effect will have possibly been muted from watching the truncated version. Suffice to say, A LOT happens after Donnie pours himself a drink!

Wow, really...? I actually thought that I had seen the HK version...but it ended with the drink then immediately cut to the beach scene...sort of a "WTF?" feeling...I reviewed the film and actually docked it a point for that ending...

Oh dear, oh dear. It appears the mainland edit has struck the members of this esteemed forum. PLEASE try to see the HK version in some form or another. The biggest complaint I've heard - online and in the real world - from people who've seen the Mainland cut, is that they were rather underwhelmed by the film as a whole, even if they thought the fights were fantastic, which I always felt was truly unfair since that mainland edit is NOT the film Wilson Yip directed.

In fact, it's the ENDING (or ENDINGS!) of the proper version that really makes the film one of the best Hong Kong movies I've ever seen. nice and dark and bleak, as any good noir film should be. I won't post spoilers here, though I'm sure you could find PLENTY online, but really, do yourselves a favour and watch the HK release, and preferably from beginning to end, because if the version you saw indeed ends with a cut from Donnie putting down a glass to Simon and the little girl on the beach, then not only are you missing an AMAZING couple of minutes in between those scenes, but ALSO many of the fights and knife-murders have been judiciously trimmed (amazing that they still hold up as well as they do!).

Oh and Bob, hopefully once you see the proper version, maybe you'll be pleased enough to restore the docked point!