Reviewed by: mrblue
You know that old urban legend about waking up in a tub with one of your kidneys missing? Would you like to see a whole movie based on that? No? Well, too bad, because here we go with Koma, a pedestrian thriller that incorporates more yawns and groans than shocks or scares. With a boring story, sub-par acting, and an annoying foot fetish displayed by the director, Koma just might end up throwing you into one of your own.
Reviewer Score: 4
Reviewed by: Sydneyguy
Summary: thriller with a twist or two
Hong kong movie makers are not known for creating thrillers.
Reviewer Score: 7
But they have done a good job here.
The cast are outstanding, which made this movie better than it should
The various plot twists was just enough to keep u at the edge of your seat.
Highly watchable, but won't be everyone's cup of tea, espcially the subject matter that is present.
Reviewed by: ewaffle
Koma is an effective suspense/horror movie that makes the unthinkable real and in doing so tries to scare the audience. It shows that in Hong Kong the price for a kidney taken from a living person is at the intersection of high-tech medicine and a market economy. That a lively trade in such organs exists is no longer an urban legend, of coursethe number of organ transplants done in the PRC is second only to the number in the United States and a significant percentage of the recipients are from overseas. The sometimes non-consensual nature of the donationsmost organs in the PRC are from condemned prisonershas stirred debate among doctors who treat those into whom the organs are transplanted, with a number of MDs in the United States unwilling on ethical grounds to treat patients whose operations took place in Mainland China.
Reviewer Score: 7
But none of this is terribly germane to the movie at hand. The two very attractive and compelling female leads create characters that we believe in, even when some of what they do is unbelievable. Angelica Lee (Ching) seems to have everythinga loving family, a huge house (with a cello used as decor) and a boyfriend who is a doctor and who adores her. Unfortunately her boyfriend is actually a loathsome creep. More unfortunately she is going to die soon from renal failure. She is cute, touching, wispy and a terrible driver. Karena Lam (Ling) lives on the wrong side of town in a crummy apartment. She has no family, no friends and a relationship with Andy Hui (Lees boyfriend, Wai) that makes the Rossellini/Hopper pairing in Blue Velvet look like Ozzie and Harriet. Her mother is comatose in some type of hospital where there seem to be plenty of nurses and other medical professionals but who leave things like treating bedsores to the patients visitors. She has a lousy life but it will go on for a long time after she attends Chings funeral.
There are enough red herrings to open a decent sized fish market, but that is par for the course in such a movie (metaphors by MixMaster). It is pretty clear early on who the kidney thief must be but the Lee and Lam are good enough and the story is just interesting enough to that we are more involved in what will happen next than in who the bad guy/girl is. There are lots of standard but still effective horror movie images. At one point early on Lee, who feels she is being stalked, is looking into a mirror. We see her back and her reflection on the left of the screen and the mirror fills right half. We think someone or something might appear suddenly in the mirror but arent really disappointed when it doesnt happen. A few minutes later after a car accident Lee is sitting shaken and weeping in the front seat of her smashed sedan when a guy pops out of the darkness and pounds on her window asking if he should call the police. Once again we expected something to happen in the window and this time it did. There are plenty of other off the shelf images and sequenceswhich is not a bad thing. They continue to be used because they work.
For example the handheld camera takes the point of view of someone sneaking up the stairs and into the bedroom of the sleeping (or is she) Ching. If it is all her nightmare, which it seems at first, then why are the French doors open and the phone line cut, just as she dreamt? People are kidnapped and left for dead but not killed, most nights are stormy, huge hospitals are left unguarded and seemingly abandoned, corridors twist and turn in ways would get any architect fired. Things that are clean are really cleana public mens room in a subway, often not the most salubrious placeis looks sterile enough to manufacture semiconductors while the medical research facility that is the setting for final confrontation looks like it hasnt been mopped in quite a while.
It may be in my mind only but I am unable to see a scene with a hand clutching a scalpel reaching out from a closing elevator door without thinking of Dressed to Kill, a terrific suspense/horror/slasher/medical movie that had its share of crazy medical professionals. The scene very late in the Koma, in which Ching sees the tips of Lings shoes under a nearby doorway and draws the wrong conclusion is also taken directly the earlier movie, a scene in which Nancy Allen is dreaming (or is she) about stalking or being stalked by Michael Caine.
Directors and writers quote other movies at their peril. Truaffaut can pay homage to Hitchcock as much as he wants and will be none the worse for it but sometimes the current movie might suffer in comparison. Still, Koma is a decent enough medical horror movie with two superb performances.
Reviewed by: tommyman
Summary: Pretty good thriller
This movie is not perfect. It has some holes in the plot but what makes up for it is the strong performances by the two leading actresses (Angelica Lee and Karena Lam). These two actresses are no doubt two of the most talented young actresses in Hong Kong and Taiwanese film business.
Reviewer Score: 7
I watched this movie with no high expectation; I bought the DVD just because I'm a big fan of Karena Lam. The movie, however, turned out to be pretty good. It is quite intense and the acting is good. The plot probably doesn't make much sense but I was still attracted to the movie till the end. The ending probably is a little too corny but the whole movie is worth spending 1 and a half hour.
7 out of 10 IMHO
Reviewed by: barrst
Summary: Close to perfect
Do youself a favor and don't read the DVD case or any reviews of this movie; watch it cold.
Angelica Lee Sin Je's character stumbles onto a horrible (yet strangely resonant) scene on her friend's wedding night. Her actions afterward start something which will destroy every constant in her life.
I'm amazed that a movie this good could have its origin in a silly urban legend. Other than some overacting and the wonky ending, this movie was thrilling to watch. Twists and turns up-end everything we think we know. The two lead actresses are perfectly matched to their roles. Everything about the movie is first rate.
Some reviews seemed to find the movie OK to bad. If all thrillers or horror movies are this good these days, I'll start watching a lot more of them!