You are currently displaying Big5
l815 (2004)
Hidden Heroes

Reviewed by: mrblue
Date: 02/03/2011

Directors Joe Ma and Soi Cheang team up with 2004's comedy/sci-fi picture Hidden Heroes, which should answer that age-old question of "What would The Terminator be like if we had the robot be played by a teenybopper pop star and mashed it up with a romantic comedy?" Well, okay, I'm sure no one's really asked that question outside of a pitch meeting held in the sixth level of Hell, but that's what we've got here. Surprisingly, the results aren't as bad as you might think.

Reviewer Score: 6

Reviewed by: Hyomil
Date: 12/31/2010

Reviewer Score: 10

Reviewed by: j.crawford
Date: 10/17/2008
Summary: Laughter is good.

I made a conscious decision to avoid Hidden Heroes when it was first released. I was, frankly, sick of Joe Ma’s recent romantic comedies and, like many others, I was not buying into The Twins hype. Over the last years, I’ve come to appreciate the comedy styling’s of Ronald Cheng so I decided to check this 2004 comedy out. I’m happy to say I was thoroughly entertained.

Producer/writer Joe Ma was smart to bring in co-director Soi Cheang and his action director Jack Wong to help with the not-so-romantic comedy elements of the film, achieving a nice visual realization. Mr. Cheng does a nice job with his character who is a quirky, not-so-well respected member of the Hong Kong detectives. He breaks off a terrific Michael Chan impersonation that had me in a fit of laughter. Gillian Cheung manages to hold her own in a dual role of comedic eye candy. What is nice is that these two actors have continued to grow as performers in all of their subsequent works.

Reviewer Score: 7

Reviewed by: JohnR
Date: 07/09/2007
Summary: A Fun Ride

I hate to just say "ditto" and be done, but there's nothing much to add to Mr. Booth's comprehensive review. I agree with all of his points, especially about this being the type of comedy only Hong Kong puts out, but hasn't recently. It's briskly paced and well put together.

I realize Ronald Cheng and Charlene Choi's presence as the leads will cause a lot of people to skip this one. I put it off a long time myself because of Cheng. Like Mr. Booth, when someone is touted to be like Stephen Chow I run in the opposite direction. But he does a good job. No, he's not on the same level as SC, but that can hardly be held against him. He puts in a good performance.

I'm a Charlene Choi fan, but I skipped this one because I heard she wasn't very good in it. It's true, her robot character is nothing to write home about, but fortunately it's not on screen a lot. (Actually, when you learn why the forger Charlene was chosen as the model for the robot, the performance makes sense; it's true to the story.) But she does well in her primary role as the forger; nothing Golden Horse-worthy but not off-putting either. I'd have preferred her to play the character less seriously, more naughty like Chingmy might have done, but at least there was no sucrose overload. Seems odd, coming down on Charlene for being too serious. What a world!

I can't see an eight, but will gladly give it a 7.5.

Reviewed by: MrBooth
Date: 10/13/2005
Summary: 8/10 - Recommended

Some years ago, Wong Jing tried to pitch Nick Cheung as "the new Stephen Chiau" - an effort that failed dismally because Nick Cheung is *not funny* and completely lacks Chiau's trademark Charisma. Skip forward a few years and the film DRAGON LOADED comes out, and people start talking about Ronald Cheng as "the new Stephen Chiau" - and I naturally avoid his films as a result. I really don't know why I decided to pick up HIDDEN HEROES in a trade, as I really didn't expect to enjoy it - but it turns out to have been a wise decision, for enjoy it I did! The "new Stephen Chiau" label fits Ronald Cheng *much* better than it ever did Nick Cheung, as he has many of the mannerisms and a style of comic delivery that will be familiar to any Chiau fan. It's easy to picture HIDDEN HEROES with Chiau in the lead role, and the film probably wouldn't be much different - or even much better!

Cheng plays Ho Yoiji (in the English subs), a cowardly, selfish and unprincipled cop who accidentally catches a major criminal, and unwittingley becomes the target of retribution from the criminal's partner. Luckily, help appears Terminator-style in the form of Charlene Choi - a robot from the future who comes to protect Ho. But there's a catch - she only plans to protect him for about a week, to make sure he dies at the "proper" time, because his timely death is important for the development of events in the future. Ho naturally doesn't see this deal as being quite what he wants, so he ends up on the run from the criminals and Miss Terminator - and when he's framed for a murder the cops are soon on his tail too. His only hope seems to be a young criminal called Mei Ling (Choi, again), who happens to be the woman on whom the robot from the future was modelled!

It's certainly not a simple story, and the script willfully indulges in convolution of a comical nature. It's one of those "anything goes" sort of films that only Hong Kong produces - and I'd forgotten just how much fun that can be! The film doesn't go so far into the Mo Lei Tau of older Chiau films that might see the characters breaking into opera or an awards ceremony, but it definitely doesn't look concerns like realism or "making sense" bother it too much. Everything is played for laughs, and they are effectively induced on numerous occasions.

It's not the sort of film where "acting" is particularly important, and most of the cast ham it up cheerfully. Here's where Cheng proves himself to be more Chiau than Cheung - his natural charisma and expressiveness carries his character and makes him plausible despite the ridiculousness of events, in a way that traditional "acting" probably couldn't do.

The supporting cast are a mixed bag in this film, with some older actors like Yuen Wah and Bonnie Wong more accustomed to the HK style of "performance" acting and fitting easily into the spirit of the film, whilst younger cast members like Raymond Wong and Charlene Choi are more awkward in their parts. Choi in particular struggles with the scenes in which she's playing her robotic form - she basically imitates roboticn emotionlessness by wearing a fixed smile and moving a little stiffly. Sadly this just comes across as bad acting. She is much better and more convincing as a human - which I suppose is a relief!

Speaking of Choi, this is another of those films where she's an object of (reciprocated) sexual desire for a significantly older man. I know neither of the Twins are teenagers anymore, but whilst Gillian has matured into a young woman, Charlene still comes across like a sassy schoolgirl (an impression not helped by her outfit when she first appears in this film!). It's hence somewhat creepy seeing scenes where she is acting in a sexual way (even though it's only innuendo). In short, Choi probably wasn't the best choice for the role, but I can't think of anyone specific I'd rather have seen, and you can't blame the film-makers for exploiting her ability to get "bums on seats". Raymond Wong is also a little miscast (he's a fine actor but not a comic), and Qin Hailu has little meat in her role but is lucky that she gets to play her character straight throughout (as I don't think she'd be able to handle comedy well either).

The film is co-directed by Joe Ma and Cheang Pou-Soi, who made a very good impression on me with LOVE BATTLEFIELD in the same year. The teaming is very effective, with Joe Ma's knack for characterisation and comedy complementing Cheang's gift for atmosphere and visual style. The film is very slick, with excellent camerawork and editing, and some pretty good special effects work. It feels like quite a high-budget film, though in truth I'm sure it was medium-sized at best. The team is clearly an effective one, and I look forward to more from them in future. Right now, I guess I'm going to have to pick up comedies of DRAGON LOADED and the other films Ronald Cheng has done since :)

Reviewer Score: 8

Reviewed by: barrst
Date: 10/20/2004
Summary: Stupid or funny, depending

From the back of the box: "Police Chi (Ronald Cheng) meets Mei Ling (Charlene Choi), a robot which comes from the future [....] Mei Ling's duty is to ensure the death of Chi [....]"

I think Hidden Heroes falls more on the Funny side in the lawless border region between Stupid and Funny, but YMMV. Charlene Choi gives a great performance.

I suspect a lot of humor was lost in translation. Movie also feels like it was filmed without much of a script, giving it more energy and unpredictability.

Worth watching if you liked Ronald Cheng's other recent comedies (Dragon Loaded and Supermodel).